Cream and buttercream – both staples in the world of baking and desserts – often lead to confusion. They sound similar, share a creamy texture (at least in their finished forms), and are both undeniably delicious. However, beneath the surface similarities lie fundamental differences in composition, flavor profiles, and culinary applications. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for any baker, whether a seasoned professional or a home enthusiast, to ensure the perfect result every time.
What is Cream?
Cream, in its simplest definition, is the portion of milk that is rich in butterfat. When fresh milk is allowed to stand, the fat, being less dense than the rest of the milk, rises to the top. This concentrated layer of fat is skimmed off to produce cream. Its defining characteristic is its high fat content, which dictates its texture, stability, and behavior when whipped or cooked.
Types of Cream
The term “cream” encompasses a wide range of products, each with a varying fat content that influences its use. The most common types include:
-
Half-and-half: Contains between 10.5% and 18% milkfat. It is too low in fat to whip properly and is generally used in coffee or as an ingredient in sauces and soups.
-
Light cream: Has a fat content of 18% to 30%. Like half-and-half, it’s not typically used for whipping but can be added to coffee or used in cooking.
-
Light whipping cream: Contains between 30% and 36% milkfat. It can be whipped, although it won’t hold its shape as well as heavy cream.
-
Heavy cream (or heavy whipping cream): Boasts a fat content of 36% or higher. This is the gold standard for whipping cream, producing stiff, stable peaks. It’s also used extensively in sauces, desserts, and other culinary applications where a rich, creamy texture is desired.
-
Double cream: Typically found in the UK, it has an even higher fat content, usually around 48%. It’s incredibly rich and thick and is often served dolloped on desserts.
How Cream is Used
Cream is a remarkably versatile ingredient with applications ranging from simple toppings to complex culinary creations.
-
Whipping: This is perhaps the most well-known application of cream. Heavy cream, in particular, whips into a light and airy topping for desserts, drinks, and more. The high fat content is essential for creating stable peaks that hold their shape.
-
Sauces: Cream adds richness and body to both sweet and savory sauces. It can be used to create creamy pasta sauces, decadent dessert sauces, or smooth and velvety soups.
-
Baking: Cream is used in a variety of baked goods to add moisture, tenderness, and flavor. It can be incorporated into cakes, cookies, scones, and other pastries.
-
Coffee and Beverages: A splash of cream can transform a simple cup of coffee into a luxurious treat. It’s also used in other beverages, such as cocktails and milkshakes.
-
Ice Cream: Cream is a fundamental ingredient in ice cream, providing the rich and creamy base that makes it so irresistible.
What is Buttercream?
Buttercream, on the other hand, is a type of frosting made primarily from butter and sugar. While cream is a single ingredient, buttercream is a confection in its own right, a blend of fats, sugars, and sometimes other flavorings, crafted to adorn cakes, cupcakes, and other sweet treats. The ratios of butter and sugar, as well as the method of preparation, determine the type of buttercream and its resulting texture and flavor.
Types of Buttercream
Buttercream is not a monolithic entity. Several distinct types exist, each with its own unique characteristics and preparation method.
-
American Buttercream (ABC): This is the simplest and most common type. It’s made by creaming together softened butter and powdered sugar, then adding liquid (such as milk or cream) and flavorings. It’s known for its sweetness and ease of preparation but can sometimes be grainy and overly sweet.
-
Swiss Meringue Buttercream (SMBC): This buttercream starts with a meringue base, made by whisking egg whites and sugar over heat until the sugar dissolves. The mixture is then whipped to stiff peaks, and softened butter is gradually added. SMBC is known for its silky smooth texture, less sweetness than ABC, and stability.
-
Italian Meringue Buttercream (IMBC): Similar to SMBC, IMBC also starts with a meringue. However, instead of heating the egg whites and sugar together, a hot sugar syrup is streamed into the whipping egg whites. This method cooks the egg whites and creates a very stable meringue. Softened butter is then added. IMBC is known for its incredibly smooth texture and ability to hold its shape well.
-
French Buttercream: This is the richest and most decadent type of buttercream. It’s made by incorporating hot sugar syrup into whipped egg yolks, then adding softened butter. French buttercream is known for its intense flavor and rich, custard-like texture.
-
German Buttercream: This buttercream involves a cooked custard base, typically made with milk, sugar, and cornstarch. The custard is cooled and then whipped with softened butter. German buttercream is known for its light and airy texture and less sweetness compared to ABC.
-
Korean Buttercream: This is not so much a buttercream in the traditional sense, but a style of decorating using Swiss or Italian Meringue Buttercream to create intricate floral designs. The focus is more on the artistry of the decorating than the specific recipe of the buttercream itself.
How Buttercream is Used
Buttercream is primarily used as a decorative and flavorful coating for cakes, cupcakes, and other desserts.
-
Frosting Cakes and Cupcakes: This is the most common application of buttercream. It provides a smooth, even surface for decorating and adds a touch of sweetness and richness.
-
Piping Decorations: Buttercream can be piped into various shapes and designs, adding intricate details to cakes and cupcakes. Different types of buttercream are better suited for different piping techniques. SMBC and IMBC are particularly well-suited for detailed piping due to their stability and smooth texture.
-
Filling for Cakes and Pastries: Buttercream can be used as a filling between layers of cake, adding moisture and flavor.
-
Stabilizing Whipped Cream: Sometimes, buttercream, particularly SMBC or IMBC, is used to stabilize whipped cream, making it more resistant to melting and holding its shape for longer periods.
Cream vs. Buttercream: Key Differences
The fundamental difference between cream and buttercream lies in their composition and purpose. Cream is a single ingredient, derived from milk, while buttercream is a prepared frosting made from butter, sugar, and other ingredients.
Composition
-
Cream: Primarily milkfat. The fat content dictates the type of cream.
-
Buttercream: A combination of butter, sugar (usually powdered sugar, granulated sugar for meringue-based versions, or sugar syrup), and often liquid (milk, cream, extracts) and flavorings.
Flavor
-
Cream: Has a subtle, milky flavor that complements other ingredients. The flavor can be enhanced with vanilla or other extracts when whipped.
-
Buttercream: The flavor is dependent on the type of buttercream and the ingredients used. American buttercream is very sweet and buttery, while Swiss and Italian meringue buttercreams are less sweet and have a more delicate flavor. French buttercream is intensely rich and custard-like.
Texture
-
Cream: Varies depending on the type. Unwhipped cream is liquid. Whipped cream is light and airy.
-
Buttercream: The texture varies widely depending on the type. American buttercream can be grainy, while Swiss and Italian meringue buttercreams are silky smooth. French buttercream is rich and custard-like. German buttercream is light and airy.
Stability
-
Cream: Whipped cream is relatively unstable and can melt or deflate quickly, especially in warm environments.
-
Buttercream: Varies depending on the type. American buttercream is relatively stable but can become soft in warm temperatures. Swiss and Italian meringue buttercreams are very stable and can hold their shape well, even in warmer conditions. French and German buttercreams are less stable than SMBC and IMBC.
Use
-
Cream: Used as an ingredient in sauces, soups, baked goods, ice cream, and as a topping for desserts and beverages.
-
Buttercream: Primarily used as a frosting and decoration for cakes, cupcakes, and other pastries.
Preparation
-
Cream: Usually requires minimal preparation, such as whipping.
-
Buttercream: Requires a specific recipe and technique, depending on the type. Some buttercreams, like SMBC and IMBC, require more advanced baking skills.
Choosing the Right Option
Selecting between cream and buttercream depends entirely on the intended use and desired outcome.
-
For a simple topping: Whipped cream is an excellent choice for topping pies, fruit salads, or hot beverages.
-
For a rich and decadent sauce: Cream is the ideal ingredient for adding richness and body to sauces, both sweet and savory.
-
For frosting a cake or cupcakes: Buttercream is the go-to choice for creating a decorative and flavorful coating.
-
For intricate piping: Swiss or Italian meringue buttercream are best suited for detailed piping work due to their stability and smooth texture.
-
For a less sweet frosting: Swiss or Italian meringue buttercream offer a less sweet alternative to American buttercream.
-
For adding moisture to baked goods: Cream can be incorporated into cake batters or pastry doughs to add moisture and tenderness.
Conclusion
While both cream and buttercream contribute to the delightful world of desserts, they are distinct entities with unique characteristics and applications. Cream, a simple dairy product rich in fat, is a versatile ingredient used in a variety of culinary creations. Buttercream, a carefully crafted confection of butter, sugar, and other ingredients, is the quintessential frosting for cakes and cupcakes. Understanding the differences between them allows bakers to make informed decisions, ensuring the perfect sweet ending every time. Knowing the nuances of each ingredient or preparation opens up a world of possibilities, transforming ordinary desserts into extraordinary culinary experiences. Whether you’re whipping up a simple dollop of cream or crafting an elaborate buttercream masterpiece, the sweet truth lies in understanding the fundamental differences between these two essential baking components.
What are the key differences between cream and buttercream frosting?
Cream, in the context of frosting, usually refers to whipped cream. This is made by whipping heavy cream until it’s light and airy. Buttercream, on the other hand, is a frosting made primarily from butter and sugar, giving it a richer, more stable texture.
The main difference lies in the ingredients and stability. Whipped cream relies on air and the fat content of the cream for its structure, making it delicate and prone to melting. Buttercream benefits from the solid fat in butter, which allows it to hold its shape much better and be used for more intricate decorations.
Which frosting is better for intricate cake decorating?
Buttercream is the clear winner when it comes to intricate cake decorating. Its robust structure allows for sculpted flowers, sharp edges, and detailed piping work that would simply be impossible with the light and unstable nature of whipped cream.
The higher fat content in buttercream lends itself to a smoother, more malleable consistency, enabling decorators to achieve a professional finish. Whipped cream, while delicious, tends to deflate and weep, making it unsuitable for anything beyond simple swirls and dollops.
How does the taste of cream frosting compare to buttercream?
Cream frosting, or whipped cream, has a very light, clean, and refreshing taste. It’s not overly sweet and provides a delicate dairy flavor that complements many desserts without overpowering them. The lightness and airiness contribute to its refreshing quality.
Buttercream, because it is primarily made of butter and sugar, is much richer and sweeter. The flavor profile can vary depending on the type of buttercream – American buttercream is the sweetest, while Swiss or Italian meringue buttercreams offer a more balanced sweetness and a smoother texture. Buttercream provides a more decadent and substantial flavor experience.
Which frosting is more stable at room temperature?
Buttercream is significantly more stable at room temperature than whipped cream. The high fat content in butter allows it to hold its shape for extended periods, making buttercream-frosted cakes suitable for display and serving at moderate temperatures.
Whipped cream, being essentially emulsified fat and air, quickly loses its structure and melts at room temperature. Cakes frosted with whipped cream must be kept refrigerated and served shortly after being removed from the refrigerator to prevent them from becoming soggy and unattractive.
Can you add flavorings and colors to cream and buttercream frostings?
Both whipped cream and buttercream can be flavored and colored, but there are some considerations. Whipped cream is more delicate and can be easily affected by added liquids, so it’s best to use powdered flavorings or extracts sparingly. Gel food coloring is preferable to liquid coloring.
Buttercream is more forgiving and can handle a wider variety of flavorings and colors. You can use extracts, liqueurs, fruit purees, and both liquid and gel food colorings. However, adding too much liquid can affect the consistency of the buttercream, so it’s important to add them gradually.
Which type of frosting is easier to make?
Whipped cream is generally considered easier and faster to make. It requires only heavy cream, sugar (optional), and a whisk or mixer. Achieving the desired consistency of stiff peaks is usually quick and straightforward.
Buttercream, depending on the type, can be more complex and time-consuming. American buttercream is the simplest, requiring only butter, powdered sugar, and liquid. However, other types like Swiss meringue buttercream or Italian meringue buttercream involve more steps and require precise temperatures and techniques.
Which frosting is best for hot weather or outdoor events?
For hot weather or outdoor events, buttercream is the far better choice. Its stability at room temperature ensures that it will hold its shape and not melt or become soupy, even in warm conditions. This makes it ideal for cakes and cupcakes that need to be displayed or transported outdoors.
Whipped cream, being extremely susceptible to heat, is entirely unsuitable for hot weather or outdoor events. It will quickly melt and lose its form, resulting in a messy and unappetizing dessert. If you are serving outdoors, avoid whipped cream altogether.